Actually, it was at least partly a joke about the oft-heard claim that Spy invented every joke ever. I wouldn't be surprised if the Spy cover was the inspiration, but it's at least equally plausible that both Hendra and Moore are giant hacks.
Alright Ned, if it is such a "major ripoff," why is Hil putting the glove on her right hand and M.M. is opting for his left hand?
Also, a Google search of the expression yielded more than 10,000 hits. While a handful referenced the movie, not one mentioned the SPY cover. (Most predated it.)
And, while I have you, how does this merit a "major" ripoff? You remind me of that dick Bill O'Reilly with his "far left," "extreme left," and "off the charts left." (Gratuitious adjectives are a pet peeve of mine, that's all I'm saying.)
I should point out that what made me think of the Spy cover is that unlike all the other examples found, both jokes are specifically about reforming America's health care system. Again, it's an obvious joke to make (and the punchline lands differently) so that doesn't prove anything. I was just struck by the similarity.
By the way, historians interested in why Spy collapsed under Hendra might want to look not just at the lame joke, or the poor (pre-?) photoshop job, but at that FONT.
Daniel, can we expect you to continue your vendetta against Moore throughout the coming media blitz? From what I've seen so far he seems to have matured a bit, and my impression is this whole "health care" thing is a "worth cause." Of course, like most do-gooders, he's probably just in it for the chicks.
Y'know, now that I think about it, I can confidently say I've never used that phrase before performing a digital rectal exam on any of my patients. This is probably because DRE's, for the most part, are not physically painful, regardless of how mentally distressing they might be. Keep in mind that the calibre of the average stool is larger than the average index finger.
I think it's safe to say this is the most inept treatment yet. Why is the patient's head finger-shaped? Why is the "doctor" pantsless, other than he must be for the "joke?" For a fairly obvious gag, there's a whole lot of desperation goin' on here.
Comments
Are you suggesting it was SPY that pioneered the grinning doctor/rubber glove bit?
Do you seriouly think the Moore ad is rip off? Or maybe a reworking of a doctor gag that's been around well before SPY came and went. (Just wondering)
Posted by: al in la | June 22, 2007 2:57 PM
You know what's awesome about that amazon link? The automated statement saying "7 of 7 people found this image helpful." I'll bet they did!
Posted by: Norman | June 22, 2007 3:32 PM
Yes, it's a major ripoff. It's not just the picture -- The caption is exactly the same: "This may hurt a little." Take another look.
They probably figured that, since Spy has been defunct for so long, nobody would notice. Wrong!
Posted by: Ned | June 22, 2007 4:50 PM
Actually, it was at least partly a joke about the oft-heard claim that Spy invented every joke ever. I wouldn't be surprised if the Spy cover was the inspiration, but it's at least equally plausible that both Hendra and Moore are giant hacks.
Posted by: radosh | June 22, 2007 10:02 PM
Actually, it was at least partly a joke about the oft-heard claim that Spy invented every joke ever.
Separated at Birth, for instance?
Posted by: Patrick Broderick | June 23, 2007 1:11 AM
Alright Ned, if it is such a "major ripoff," why is Hil putting the glove on her right hand and M.M. is opting for his left hand?
Also, a Google search of the expression yielded more than 10,000 hits. While a handful referenced the movie, not one mentioned the SPY cover. (Most predated it.)
And, while I have you, how does this merit a "major" ripoff? You remind me of that dick Bill O'Reilly with his "far left," "extreme left," and "off the charts left." (Gratuitious adjectives are a pet peeve of mine, that's all I'm saying.)
Posted by: al in la | June 23, 2007 7:59 AM
I should point out that what made me think of the Spy cover is that unlike all the other examples found, both jokes are specifically about reforming America's health care system. Again, it's an obvious joke to make (and the punchline lands differently) so that doesn't prove anything. I was just struck by the similarity.
By the way, historians interested in why Spy collapsed under Hendra might want to look not just at the lame joke, or the poor (pre-?) photoshop job, but at that FONT.
Posted by: radosh | June 23, 2007 11:10 AM
Daniel, can we expect you to continue your vendetta against Moore throughout the coming media blitz? From what I've seen so far he seems to have matured a bit, and my impression is this whole "health care" thing is a "worth cause." Of course, like most do-gooders, he's probably just in it for the chicks.
Posted by: jake | June 23, 2007 11:49 AM
also, he says "might," and she says, "may."
Posted by: jake | June 23, 2007 11:50 AM
Y'know, now that I think about it, I can confidently say I've never used that phrase before performing a digital rectal exam on any of my patients. This is probably because DRE's, for the most part, are not physically painful, regardless of how mentally distressing they might be. Keep in mind that the calibre of the average stool is larger than the average index finger.
Oh, hell. Did I just kill the funny again?
Posted by: Michael | June 23, 2007 10:11 PM
Regardless of the blatant ripoff cover, it's a worth seeing the movie.
Posted by: mypalmike | June 27, 2007 2:20 AM
(That's my Italian voice...)
Posted by: mypalmike | June 27, 2007 2:21 AM
Just in case anyone happens across this...
Here's yet another use of the same theme that appeared right around the time of this thread:
http://www.comics.com/editoons/huffaker/archive/images/huffaker2007305500628.gif
I think it's safe to say this is the most inept treatment yet. Why is the patient's head finger-shaped? Why is the "doctor" pantsless, other than he must be for the "joke?" For a fairly obvious gag, there's a whole lot of desperation goin' on here.
Posted by: Vance | July 30, 2007 3:30 PM